Pour cornmeal into a dry skillet and over medium heat toast until lightly browned for 3-5 minutes. Do not leave unattended and stir with a wooden spoon to ensure all cornmeal granules are toasted evenly. Pour toasted cornmeal into a bowl and set aside.
In a large nonstick skillet, melt the kaymak over medium heat. Continue to allow the kaymak to bubble for a few minutes.
Add the cornmeal and mix into the kaymak with a large wooden spoon.
Stir the cornmeal for several minutes until it changes color to a deep golden brown.
When the oil from the kaymak begins to separate, add the water and bring it to a boil. Once the water has reached a boil, slowly add the grated cheese.
Stir the mixture constantly while adding cheese to allow it to melt and the mixture to develop a smooth texture.
Let the cornmeal cheese mixture cook over low heat, stirring occasionally until you see the butter rise to the top.
Serve hot topped with freshly cracked pepper and sourdough bread for scooping.